I also consider GitHub’s behaviour deficient just because it allows to reply to email notifications, and the chance of you missing important info is higher, as I pointed out in Bug 1510831. That’s a big difference from Bugzilla. While GitHub is obviously better than Bugzilla in many aspects, it’s still sending a whole bunch of email notifications, and that’s not what I want to see. My UX inspiration is rather Slack. Anyway, many modern apps allow to edit your comments (one exception is Twitter) but probably the most don’t notify changes via email. I’ll ask Bugzilla admins to get some insights from people’s comment editing history.
Bug 1524884 Comment 4 Edit History
Note: The actual edited comment in the bug view page will always show the original commenter’s name and original timestamp.
I also consider GitHub’s behaviour deficient just because it allows to reply to email notifications, and the chance of you missing important info is higher, as I pointed out in Bug 1510831. That’s a big difference from Bugzilla. While GitHub is obviously better than Bugzilla in many aspects, it’s still sending a whole bunch of email notifications, and that’s not what I want to see. My UX inspiration is rather Slack. Anyway, many modern apps allow to edit your comments (one exception is Twitter) but probably the most of them don’t notify the changes via email. I’ll ask Bugzilla admins to get some insights from people’s comment editing history.